Post details: Checkpoint USA Is Going To Trial!

2012-02-17

Permalink 07:19:23, Categories: Roadblock Lawsuit, Checkpoints, Sobriety, 477 words   English (EU)

Checkpoint USA Is Going To Trial!

After more than eight long years, hundreds of legal documents later and several court challenges (including a reversal by the 9th circuit court of appeals), Checkpoint USA's lawsuit is finally being scheduled for trial after being launched in December 2003 against an illegal checkpoint operation conducted in December of 2002.

[More:]

The last hurdle to trial was overcome on January 23, 2012 when United States Circuit Judge Wallace Tashima (sitting by designation) denied our motion for summary judgment, denied the defendant's motion for summary judgment with regards to whether or not the checkpoint was conducted as an exercise in general law enforcement and ordered a final pre-trial conference for setting trial dates.

The court orders referred to above are available on this website at:

I encourage folks to not only read the judge's summary judgment order above but also the original motions for summary judgment from the defendants (TOPD police) and the plaintiff (Checkpoint USA) to get a feel for why it can be so difficult to hold police officers accountable within the judicial system.

Of note in the court order is the granting of summary judgment on one key issue in favor of the defendants. The issue was whether or not the actions of individual officers at the checkpoint were reasonable & their discretion appropriately limited. This is separate and distinct from the question of whether or not the checkpoint itself was conducted for general law enforcement purposes.

Under the current system, in order for a plaintiff to overcome a claim of qualified immunity by a police defendant, the plaintiff must show that the law was 'clearly established' and the officers knowingly violated it. In this case, the court effectively ruled there was enough evidence for a claim that the police officers were knowingly violating the law but because 'case law' has not established that their actions were clearly illegal, they are entitled to qualified immunity. In other words, a 'cop' out for cops.

Regardless of the partial granting of summary judgment in favor of the defendants however, we still go to trial on the most important issue of all. That issue is whether or not the defendants illegally expanded the scope of a lawful sobriety checkpoint into an illegal general law enforcement dragnet operation.

The motions for summary judgment and various responses from both parties giving rise to the court order discussed earlier appear below. Additional exhibits associated with the motions are also available in the lawsuit's document timeline:

Comments:

Comment from: Ken [Visitor]
Looking for address, Time of Day and date. Please post.
Permalink 2012-03-03 @ 17:41
Comment from: Doug [Visitor]
Thx for posting all this material. It is very interesting. It bothers me that the court is so eager to grant immunity to police officers. The courts seem quite reluctant to hold police accountable for illegal actions.
Permalink 2012-03-03 @ 23:57
Comment from: Event dj adelaide [Visitor] · http://platinumdjs.com.au
This is the first time I've been to your site. Thank you for posting more details.
Permalink 2012-03-10 @ 07:52
Comment from: Checkpoint USA [Member]
Trial dates haven't been set yet but the final PreTrial Conference is scheduled for March 19th at 2:00pm at Tucson Federal District Court
Permalink 2012-03-17 @ 00:00

Comments are closed for this post.

Roadblock Revelations

Welcome to Checkpoint USA's blog. Here you'll find general information and discussions regarding growing threats to our right to privacy & travel.

While I refer to court cases along with state and federal law frequently in this blog, nothing written here should be construed as legal advice. I am not an attorney. Rather, I'm someone concerned about the growing disregard for individual rights present at all levels of government.

My conclusions are my own based upon personal experience and research. The law is made purposely complex however and varies significantly from place to place and circumstance to circumstance.

April 2014
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
<<  <   >  >>
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30        

Search

Categories


Misc

Syndicate this blog XML

What is RSS?

powered by
b2evolution